Surprising Harry Potter Fan Theories

May 21, 2020Silvia Fonseca

The universe of the Harry Potter saga, created by British writer J. K. Rowling is so rich that it allows endless reinterpretations. This, and the fact that every fan wants to keep the young wizard's adventures alive forever, make people invent many theories. Some are more surprising than others, and they include many clues hidden in the books and even secret connections between the characters. Want to discover some of them? Keep reading.

The Etymology of the Word Abracadabra

You don't have to be a genius to realize the similarity between the Muggle word "abracadabra" and "Avada Kedavra." But this Reddit user links the resemblance to a relationship between wizards and muggles that existed before the Secrecy Statute was passed in 1692.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Leah Anderson - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

Another user suggests that the curse was initially used to cure or kill diseases. This makes a lot of sense because, as the Huffington Post pointed out, at one moment in history, people thought that "abracadabra" could cure the symptoms of bubonic plague.

Ten Points to Neville in the Philosopher's Stone

During the holiday banquet in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, Dumbledore rewards the houses with points for Harry, Ron, and Hermione for successfully defeating Voldemort. He also gives Neville 10 points because, as he says, "it takes a great deal of courage to face our enemies, but even more to face our friends."

Image Credits: Pinterest/moviesprism - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

This Quora user points out that Dumbledore might know precisely how much bravery it takes. That is because he had to fight his best friend Grindelwald as well. So maybe the points were out of empathy for Neville.

Divinations Exercise in The Goblet of Fire

In The Goblet of Fire, Harry and Ron give up their divination exercise and decide to completely invent their predictions. This Tumblr user says that what they predict seems to be what happens to Harry throughout the rest of the book.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Business Insider France - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire

He is put "at risk of burns" during the First Task, "loses his most precious treasure" during the Second Task, and he is "stabbed in the back" by a friend, Professor Moody. And, finally, "fails in a fight" against his enemy.

The Dursleys Attitude

The Dursleys may be so mean to Harry because he was a Horcrux. We already know how being very close to a Horcrux makes Ron more than a little horrible. But the Dursleys lived with Harry for years. That makes us wonder...

Image Credits: Pinterest/Bustle - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

While no one is saying that Harry's family would have been otherwise charming, having pieces of Voldemort living in their house probably didn't help. Do you think they might have been different without Harry living with them?

Hermione's Cat Belonged to the Potters

This Quora user has an incredible theory that Crookshank was actually Lily Potter's cat. When Hermione buys it at Magical Menagerie, in Diagon Alley, the owner says that they had the cat "for a long time."

Image Credits: Pinterest/We Heart It - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

The theory is made stronger by the fact that Crookshanks immediately recognizes Wormtail and Sirius in their animagus forms. Why is that? The user says it is because they would have visited the Potters frequently in Godric's Hollow.

Child of an Enchantment

Exploring a little more of Voldemort's past, we find another interesting theory: that the villain would be unable to know a pure feeling like love and that, therefore, he would have been so shattered by the protection that Lily gave to young Harry.

Image Credits: Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

This is due to the fact that the love between Voldemort's parents happened in a fabricated and artificial way, since his mother, Mérope, enchanted Tom Riddle with a love potion. Because of this, he would be the result of enchantment and not true love.

Hufflepuff's Secret

According to some people, the Hufflepuffs take some kind of medicine. They are the kindest, they accept almost everyone, they are not overly concerned with athletic or academic performance, and even their common room is right next to the kitchen.

Image Credits: Flickr/byzantiumbooks

Because all of that some people theorize that they might consume something special to keep them so happy. Probably it has to do with the head of Hufflepuff, which is the Professor of Herbology. Hey, whatever it is, we are not judging!

Hermione Chose Her Own House

It's explicitly made clear in the first harry potter movie that Harry chooses Gryffindor. The Sorting Hat thought he was better suited for Slytherin, but Potter was firmly opposed to it. Some people believe that Hermione chose her house like him.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Buzzfeed - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

Everyone knows that Hermione would make a fantastic Ravenclaw. So why did she ended up in Gryffindor?  According to some Quora users, Hermione chose this house because she admired its bravery, and wanted to prove that she could be brave herself.

More Attractive to Dementors

This Reddit user points out that, as Harry was a Horcrux, he had a little more soul than everyone else. So, maybe that's why he would be more attractive to Dementors. This, however, contradicts an explanation given on the books.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Jacki Davis - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Although Lupin explains to Harry that the Dementors are more interested in him because of the horrible things he has experienced in his past, that could be the real reason. And it would explain why they don't seem to be interested in other people with similarly sad backgrounds, like Neville.

Voldemort and the Destruction of His Horcruxes

Although different wizards destroyed all seven of Voldemort's Horcruxes, this Quora user theorizes that the destruction of them was made possible by Voldemort. Five of the Horcruxes, the diary, the medallion, the cup, the ring, and Nagini, were destroyed using the poison of Basilisk. That was either from the fangs of Basilisk himself or using the sword of Gryffindor, which was impregnated with the poison.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Aliya Bornstein - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

Voldemort opened the Chamber of Secrets, thus, allowing access to the Basilisk in the first place. A Fiendfyre cast destroyed the diadem, a spell taught to Crabbe by Voldemort's Death Eaters. And the final one, Harry, was destroyed by Voldemort himself.

Professor Dumbledore's Great Role

This theory is that, throughout the entire length of the story, Professor Dumbledore was playing a complicated game, thinking of many moves ahead. The objective of the game is to win the war against Voldemort. However, Harry is introduced to the game when he is very young, and, to properly prepare him for the final battle, Dumbledore resorts to different antics.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Jeíla Fernandes - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

Many details are confirmed by the fact that all the tests were prepared by Dumbledore, especially for Harry. For example, in the beginning, it can be observed that an artifact as dangerous as the Philosopher's Stone is protected by tests that a first-year student can overcome. The omniscient teacher, although he remains behind the scenes, influences from there all the events. 

Harry and Hemione are Siblings

We know almost nothing about Hermione's parents, other than the fact that they are dentists. Also, she even had the ability to erase her family's memory and send them to Australia near the end of the story.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Livingly - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets

Another important fact about this theory is that Hermione knew she had a connection with Harry, and if she had Lilly's blood, she would be magically able to protect him, just like his mother. This would explain why Hermione was always close to Harry from the beginning. Only a blood connection could explain such dedication.

Dumbledore and the Mirror of Erised

Presented in the first book of the saga, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, the Mirror of Erised is a magical object that provides its user with a view of his most intimate desire. Through it, Harry finds himself next to his parents and the rest of the Potter family.

Image Credits: Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

Who also saw something in the mirror was Albus Dumbledore. When Harry asks what he sees, the director replies that he finds himself holding a pair of socks. Harry is suspicious but says nothing. However, with the revelations given in The Deathly Hallows, many theorize that Albus sees himself next to his family, alive and reconciled, and J.K. Rowling herself confirmed this.

The Weasleys and British Royalty

An interesting theory about the franchise: all the names of the members of the Weasley family, except Ron, belong to members of the British royalty or Arthurian legends. Also, Ron brings Harry to his family. There have already been eight kings named Harry in power.

Image Credits: Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

However, this is just the tip of the iceberg. The biggest curiosity here concerns the fact that King George III is deaf in one ear and only became king due to the death of Prince Frederick. Does that remind you of anything? That's precisely what happens in the movies.

Weasley Twins and Patronus

So check this other theory about the Weasley twins out: The Patronus of each wizard always have a special connection to another person in the world, their "soul mates." This also explains why Ron's Patronus is a terrier dog, and Hermione's is an otter, as terriers chase otters.

Image Credits: Pinterest/Yahoo - Warner Bros Pictures/Harry Potter Saga

However, after Fred's death, it is speculated that George was never able to produce a Patronus again, and this is mainly due to the loss of his true soul mate: his own brother. Too sad, right?

Over the years, interest in books and films about Harry Potter has not diminished. The fans are creating different theories, trying to observe something more in the actions of the characters, putting the pieces together as if they were a puzzle. Which of these hypotheses surprised you the most?

You May Also Like