logo
A close-up of a young elf-girl | Source: AmoMedia
A close-up of a young elf-girl | Source: AmoMedia

The Elven Queen Banished Her 10-Year-Old Granddaughter for Having No Magic – But When an Old Dwarf Butler Brought Out a Wooden Box, She Screamed, 'Don't Open It!'

author
By Nataliia Riabtseva-Tsapenko
Nov 13, 2026
05:03 A.M.
Share this pen
FacebookFacebookXXLinkedInLinkedInEmailEmail

On my tenth birthday, my grandmother decided I wasn't worthy of being an elven princess. I thought losing my place in the palace would be the worst part.

Advertisement

"Again, Ivy!"

I raised my hands toward the crystal.

Nothing happened.

"Please," I whispered. "Just one little spark."

"Again, Ivy!"

The crystal stayed dark.

Grandmother sighed loudly.

"Ten years old, and not a drop of magic."

"I'm trying!"

"Your cousins could summon flowers when they were five!"

"I'm trying!"

Advertisement

Behind her throne, my cousins giggled, their silver circlets glittering.

One flicked her fingers.

Pink butterflies appeared above her head.

Show-off.

One flicked her fingers.

I'd practiced every night for months.

I'd tried candles, flowers, even a spoon.

The spoon hadn't moved.

"Perhaps she's tired, Your Majesty," Barnaby said.

Our old dwarf butler stood near the doors, his palace badge shining.

Advertisement

I'd tried candles.

"Silence, dwarf!" Grandmother snapped.

He bowed.

"Of course, Your Majesty. Apologies."

Queen Elsa ruled our kingdom from a palace of white stone.

She was also my grandmother.

"Silence, dwarf!"

Advertisement

Unfortunately, she preferred being queen instead of anything else.

"Take off your crown, Ivy."

I touched my silver circlet.

"Why?"

She preferred being queen.

"Because you don't deserve to wear it."

"But Grandfather gave it to me..."

"And King Silas isn't here to protect you anymore. Take it off!"

My throat tightened.

"Grandfather gave it to me..."

Advertisement

Grandfather had been gone for two years. Grandmother had grown colder since.

My parents were gone, too.

They'd died in a battle of magic when I was a baby.

I knew them from portraits and stories Grandfather used to tell.

He said my mother could make rain dance. My father could turn moonlight into music.

My parents were gone.

I'd spent years wondering which gift I'd inherited.

Apparently, neither.

Grandfather never asked me to prove myself. He'd taught me to grow flowers with water and patience.

Advertisement

Grandmother made me try magic every day.

"But he said I'd always be a princess," I whispered.

Apparently, neither.

"Then he made a promise he couldn't keep, girl."

"Can I try again tomorrow?"

"No. You're leaving the palace today, Ivy."

I stared at her.

"Leaving? Where?"

"Can I try again tomorrow?"

Advertisement

"That's no longer my concern."

The guards approached.

"Please, Grandmother. I'll work harder!"

"You've had ten years to prove yourself."

I removed my circlet.

The guards approached.

Nobody moved to help me.

Except Barnaby.

"Your Majesty, surely we can find another solution."

"Would you like to leave with her, dwarf?"

He lowered his head.

Advertisement

Nobody moved to help me.

"No, Your Majesty."

That hurt.

Grandmother pointed toward the doors.

"Take her away."

"Wait," Barnaby said.

Grandmother turned.

"No, Your Majesty."

Advertisement

"What now? You're walking a fine line, dwarf."

"There's something we must settle first."

He disappeared through a side door.

When he returned, he carried a wooden box.

Its brass lock was rusty.

"What now?"

Grandmother's face changed.

"Barnaby. Put that down!"

He walked toward me.

"Did you hear me?"

Barnaby knelt and handed me a key.

Advertisement

"Did you hear me?"

"Princess, this belongs to you."

I slipped it into the lock.

Grandmother rushed down the throne steps.

"Ivy! Don't open it!"

I turned the key.

"This belongs to you."

Advertisement

***

Inside lay a small green book.

Golden letters crawled across its cover.

"Is this a spell book?"

"Not exactly, Princess Ivy," Barnaby said.

Grandmother reached for it.

Inside lay a small green book.

I stepped aside.

"You're banishing me. Why can't I keep one book?"

The cover opened by itself.

A page turned.

Advertisement

Then another.

A page turned.

My cousin's name appeared.

  • "Three flowers summoned."
  • "Twenty years of magic owed."

I frowned.

"Why does my cousin owe 20 years? Twenty years of what, Grandmother?"

Grandmother stopped reaching and stood up straight, her eyes wide.

"Three flowers summoned."

Advertisement

"Give me that."

"Twenty years of what?" I asked.

"You're too young to understand."

"Then explain it."

My cousin stepped forward.

"Give me that."

"Those were my flowers!"

Barnaby glanced at her crystal.

"Would you summon another?"

She raised her hand.

Barnaby glanced at her.

Advertisement

A rose sprang from the floor.

The book flashed.

  • "Twenty-one years owed."

My cousin gasped.

A rose sprang.

Grandmother grabbed her crystal.

"Enough!"

I stared at the page.

"She made one rose. Why did another year get added to the book?"

Grandmother held out her hand.

"Enough!"

Advertisement

"Now, Ivy."

I shut the book.

"No."

The guards shifted. I knew they wouldn't attack me, but if their queen commanded it, they wouldn't have much of a choice.

"Now, Ivy."

"Are you defying me?"

"You told me to leave, Grandmother."

I picked up my circlet.

"So I'm taking Grandfather's present with me."

"Are you defying me?"

Advertisement

Barnaby opened the doors.

"Come along, Princess."

"You may stay until sunset!" Grandmother called after us. "Then I want you gone!"

I followed him into the gardens.

"Come along, Princess."

Grandmother didn't send the guards after us.

***

Outside, silver birds circled the fountains.

Blue roses sang whenever someone passed.

I'd always loved those gardens.

Advertisement

Silver birds circled.

Now I wondered who'd paid the price for them.

"Barnaby, what does the book mean?"

He sat beside me.

"Your grandmother uses her own magic to lend power through those crystals."

He sat beside me.

Advertisement

"So?"

"Every spell creates a future debt. When the children grow older, the Queen collects their magic."

"For how long?"

"However many years they owe."

"So Grandmother gets stronger?"

"For how long?"

"Yes."

"And they get weaker?"

Barnaby nodded.

"That's a terrible present."

"She's already collecting from the older elves," Barnaby said.

Advertisement

"Yes."

I opened the book.

Hundreds of names filled the pages.

"Does Grandmother know?"

"She invented the arrangement, Princess."

I looked up.

"Does Grandmother know?"

Advertisement

"And you knew, too?"

Barnaby rubbed his beard.

"Yes."

"You watched me practice every night?"

"Yes."

"Yes."

"You watched her laugh at me?"

His shoulders dropped.

"Ivy, your grandfather asked me to protect you."

"By doing nothing?"

He didn't answer.

"By doing nothing?"

Advertisement

I pushed the book against his chest.

"Why bring it out now?"

"King Silas left instructions. If the queen ever cast you out, I was to give you the truth."

"And if she hadn't?"

"Why bring it out now?"

Barnaby looked away.

I stood.

"You should've told me sooner."

"You're right. I should have."

I snatched the book back.

Barnaby looked away.

Advertisement

"Then help me do something useful with it."

Barnaby glanced toward the palace.

"Her Majesty offered me a cottage once."

"For what?"

"Then help me do something useful with it."

"Keeping quiet about the book."

I stared at him.

"Did you take it?"

"No."

"Then why didn't you tell anyone?"

"No."

Advertisement

He looked at his polished shoes.

"Because I was afraid of losing my place here."

I hugged the book tighter.

"Well, I'm losing mine anyway."

I hugged the book tighter.

***

My cousin found us beside the fountain.

"Grandmother says you've stolen a royal book. We've all been told to take you to her if we see you."

"She gave me no choice about leaving."

"She says you're lying about our magic."

Advertisement

My cousin found us.

I opened her page.

"Make the fountain bloom," I said.

My cousin raised her crystal.

Golden vines burst from the water.

They climbed the fountain, wrapping around a stone frog.

"Make the fountain bloom."

Advertisement

The book flashed.

  • "Twenty-two years owed."

"That's impossible!" she cried.

"Then refuse the next spell."

"But the vines won't stop!"

"That's impossible!"

Barnaby stepped forward.

"Tell the crystal you refuse its gift."

"I refuse!"

The vines stopped.

"I refuse!"

Advertisement

One dropped the stone frog into the water.

Splash!

Barnaby wiped his beard.

"Well. That was dramatic."

The book didn't change.

Splash!

"Will I lose my magic?"

"Barnaby?" I asked. "Will she?"

He stepped closer.

"Your own gift can still grow. Refusing borrowed magic prevents another debt."

"Will she?"

Advertisement

My cousin looked toward the palace.

"Grandmother said I was special."

I wanted to say something mean.

After all, she'd laughed at me.

I wanted to say something mean.

But her hands were shaking.

So I handed her the book.

"You're still special without that crystal."

She studied her page.

Then she ran toward the palace.

She studied her page.

Advertisement

I hoped she'd tell the others.

I was wrong.

***

Grandmother found me beneath the golden tree.

She carried a glowing crystal.

"Ivy, darling."

I was wrong.

I nearly dropped the book.

She hadn't called me darling in years.

"I've reconsidered your punishment."

"Really?"

"Perhaps you deserve another chance."

Advertisement

"Really?"

She held out the crystal.

A tiny golden bird appeared.

It landed on my finger.

Its feathers felt warm.

She held out the crystal.

Advertisement

"With this, you could summon 100 birds."

I watched it sing.

"Could I make flowers, too?"

"Of course, Ivy. Whatever you want."

I imagined standing beside my cousins.

I watched it sing.

Everyone clapping.

Grandmother smiling at me.

"What would I have to do?"

"Put that dreadful book away. Burn it, even."

Everyone clapping.

Advertisement

The bird fluttered onto my shoulder.

I touched its wings.

"How much would I owe?"

Grandmother's smile faded.

"That isn't important."

Grandmother's smile faded.

"Is it more than 20 years?"

"Enough questions, girl!"

The bird vanished.

I handed the crystal back.

"Then I don't want it."

The bird vanished.

Advertisement

Grandmother stared at me.

"You'd rather remain powerless?"

I looked at my empty hands.

"I'd rather keep what's mine."

Grandmother stared.

Her expression hardened.

"Your grandfather spent his whole life protecting people who should have learned to protect themselves."

That reminded me of something.

***

When I was six, Grandfather found me crying beside a flowerpot.

Advertisement

Her expression hardened.

I'd spent all afternoon trying to grow a seed.

Nothing happened.

"Stubborn little thing," he said.

"The seed?"

"No. You, my Ivy."

"Stubborn little thing."

Advertisement

He sat beside me.

"Grandfather, why don't I have magic?"

He took a silver circlet from his pocket.

"Happy birthday, sweet girl."

"But I didn't grow the flower."

He sat beside me.

"Then we'll grow it another way."

He helped me plant another seed.

We watered it.

"Will it work?"

"Not today."

Advertisement

"Then why bother?"

"Because some things take time."

He placed the circlet on my head.

"It's not a prize, Ivy. It's yours."

"Then why bother?"

***

"Why did Grandfather leave you the book?"

"Because the Queen wanted it destroyed."

"And you kept it?"

"For two years."

"You were afraid of her."

Advertisement

"For two years."

"Yes."

"So was I."

Barnaby looked down.

I opened the book. My name wasn't there.

Grandfather had refused to let her lend me magic.

He'd never cared that I couldn't make my own.

"So was I."

Advertisement

"Barnaby, can Grandmother cancel the debts?"

He hesitated.

"Yes."

"How?"

"There's a final page."

I flipped through the book.

"There's a final page."

The last page was tied shut. I hoped it wasn't spelled shut, too.

"Why didn't you tell me?"

"Because canceling the debts costs the lender her magic."

I pulled the ribbon.

Advertisement

"Why didn't you tell me?"

Golden letters appeared.

"All debts may be forgiven.

The lender must surrender her own magic."

"Grandmother could free everyone?"

Barnaby nodded.

Golden letters appeared.

Advertisement

"But she'd lose her power."

I closed the book.

"Then I'm going to ask her."

***

By afternoon, the palace gardens were packed.

Grandmother hadn't canceled my birthday celebration.

She'd turned it into a display of my cousins' talents.

I closed the book.

Grandmother stood beneath the golden tree.

Silver birds carried ribbons overhead.

Flowers changed colors when guests applauded.

Advertisement

My cousins lined up with their crystals.

"Watch this, Ivy!" one called.

One summoned blue roses.

"Watch this, Ivy!"

Another made silver butterflies.

"Grandmother says we're performing for everyone tonight."

"Does she?" I asked.

"She's very proud of us."

I opened the book.

"Does she?"

Advertisement

New debts appeared.

I hurried toward the fountain.

"Stop!"

My cousins turned.

"You're making the debts bigger."

New debts appeared.

One shook her head.

"Grandmother says you invented that."

"Then look."

I showed them the page.

"We'll lose our place at court."

"Then look."

Advertisement

"You'll lose more if you keep using those crystals."

"Then what are we supposed to do?"

"Ask Grandmother why she never told you."

The oldest cousin grabbed the book.

"You're jealous because you can't do anything!"

"You'll lose more."

That stung.

"Maybe I am!"

They stared at me.

"You get flowers and birds. I get an empty crystal."

My voice shook.

Advertisement

"Maybe I am!"

"But nobody told you those tricks had a price."

My cousin looked down.

Then she shoved the book back.

"We're telling Grandmother."

They hurried away.

"But nobody told you."

Advertisement

I wanted to chase them.

Instead, I went straight to the celebration.

***

Grandmother raised her hands.

"Today, we honor the magic of our youngest elves!"

The crowd cheered.

I wanted to chase them.

I stopped beside the stone bench.

"What if nobody believes me?" I whispered.

Barnaby looked at the book.

"Then show them."

Advertisement

"And if Grandmother gets angry?"

I stopped beside the stone bench.

"She will."

I swallowed.

"That's not very comforting."

"No," he said. "But it's honest."

I climbed onto the bench.

"IT'S BORROWED! ALL THE MAGIC IS BORROWED!"

"She will."

Advertisement

Nobody heard me.

"Her Majesty's granddaughter wishes to speak!"

Everyone turned.

Wonderful.

Nobody heard me.

I gripped the book.

Grandmother's smile vanished.

"Get down, Ivy."

"Not until they see this."

I gripped the book.

Advertisement

"Every spell adds a debt. You'll collect it when the children are older. And when you collect those debts, you'll grow stronger, won't you, Grandmother?"

Grandmother laughed.

"A child has misunderstood a royal gift."

"Then why didn't you tell us its price?"

Grandmother laughed.

"Because children would never agree if they knew!"

The garden went quiet.

"Then you knew it was unfair," I said.

Grandmother pressed her lips together.

Advertisement

"Give it to me."

The garden went quiet.

I nearly read my cousin's debt aloud.

Then I saw her watching.

She looked miserable.

I closed the book.

"No. She can choose whether to show them."

I saw her watching.

Advertisement

Grandmother smiled.

"How convenient. You're making this up, Ivy. Dear child, you're testing my patience."

I offered my cousin the book.

She opened her page.

"She's telling the truth."

Grandmother smiled.

A few parents pushed forward to see the book.

Grandmother clapped sharply.

"Enough. Children, prepare the final display."

My cousins raised their crystals.

Advertisement

Grandmother clapped sharply.

The golden tree shook. Silver birds soared overhead.

Grandmother watched proudly as their borrowed magic filled the garden.

I stepped between my cousins.

"You don't have to do it."

The golden tree shook.

Advertisement

"Stand aside!" Grandmother ordered.

"Every spell gives her more of your future power!"

One cousin lowered her crystal.

Another followed.

Then the oldest cousin set hers down.

"Stand aside!"

The golden tree stopped shaking.

The fountain became ordinary water.

The old debts remained in the book.

But no new ones appeared.

"Those gifts belong to me!" Grandmother shouted.

Advertisement

"Then keep them," I said.

"Those gifts belong to me!"

***

Grandmother stepped toward me.

"You've ruined everything."

"Not yet."

I opened the final page.

"There's a way to cancel the debts."

"Not yet."

Advertisement

Her face went pale.

"Close that book."

"Why?"

Barnaby stepped forward.

"The Queen would have to surrender her own magic."

"Why?"

I looked at Grandmother.

"You could give it all back."

"And become powerless?"

"You told me being powerless was shameful."

"Because it is!"

Advertisement

My cousins stared at her.

"And become powerless?"

"I've kept this kingdom magnificent for decades!" Grandmother snapped. "Our gardens bloom in winter. Our fountains never run dry."

"And the children of the kingdom pay for it?"

"They receive wonders in return."

"Did they agree?"

"Their families accepted my gifts."

"Did they agree?"

Advertisement

"Then cancel the debts."

Grandmother stepped back.

"And lose my magic? Never!"

My cousin removed her silver circlet and placed it beside her crystal.

Another cousin did the same.

Grandmother stared.

"Put those back on!"

Grandmother stepped back.

I held up the book.

"Your magic belongs to you, Grandmother. And theirs belongs to them."

***

Advertisement

Grandmother pointed at my silver circlet.

"Take that off!"

I touched the little crown Grandfather had given me.

"No."

"Take that off!"

Barnaby removed his palace badge and set it beside the crystals.

Then he picked up my bag.

"Where shall we go, Princess?"

"Somewhere with cake."

He smiled.

"An excellent choice."

Advertisement

"Somewhere with cake."

We walked toward the gates.

Behind us, Grandmother ordered the flowers to bloom.

They did.

But nobody turned to watch.

Advertisement

Related posts