I'd spent 35 years handling stubborn children, but my husband was another story. I cured his sudden deafness with one question to his best friend. But I wasn't prepared for what followed.
At eighty, I'd survived childbirth, menopause, thirty-five years of teaching, and fifty-eight years of marriage to Walter.
But nothing prepared me for his sudden hearing loss.
"Walter, the kitchen sink is clogged again."
Silence.
Nothing prepared me for his sudden hearing loss.
"Walter?"
My husband sat three feet away, watching television like a man defusing a bomb.
"There's pie in the refrigerator."
"Interesting. Your ears work when dessert is involved."
Silence.
"What?"
I lowered my glasses, giving him the look I'd perfected during thirty-five years as a schoolteacher.
"Two out of ten, Walter. See me after class."
"Birdie, I haven't been in school for sixty-four years!"
"And somehow, you're still my worst student."
Your ears work when dessert is involved.
Walter chuckled. "After fifty-eight years of marriage, I still can't get a passing grade?"
"Not until you start listening, sweetheart."
I'd spent my career catching children faking stomachaches. My husband wasn't fooling me either.
"Walter, did you really think I wouldn't notice?"
"Can't hear you, Trouble."
You're still my worst student.
Sometimes I missed the man who used to pull me away from the dishes just to dance.
Now I could barely pull him away from the television.
I glanced at the floor beside his chair.
"Pick up those socks."
"What socks?"
My husband wasn't fooling me either.
"The ones beside your recliner. I'm considering charging them rent."
Then there were his dentures.
Our five-year-old great-granddaughter had discovered them beside the butter dish.
"Grandma, why is breakfast smiling at me?"
I could barely pull him away from the television.
Walter found that hilarious.
He'd laughed just as hard when I once spat my dentures into his dinner plate. Since then, 'Holy dentures!' had been my favorite cry whenever disaster struck.
His doctor had already confirmed that his hearing was perfectly normal.
"Did you check the part responsible for listening to wives?" I'd asked.
I'm considering charging them rent.
The doctor laughed.
Walter said, "What?"
That was when I decided medical science needed help.
Walter owned a fishing rod worth nearly two thousand dollars. He polished it more often than his shoes.
Once, during a thunderstorm, he'd carried it upstairs before checking whether I'd gotten inside.
Holy dentures!' had been my favorite cry.
"That rod is an investment," he'd explained.
"So was our marriage. Yet here I am, depreciating."
Now, I had an investment opportunity of my own.
I entered our bedroom, closed the door, and called Ronald, Walter's best friend.
"Hello, Ronald, sweetheart!"
I decided medical science needed help.
"Birdie? Why are you calling me sweetheart?"
I spoke loudly enough to reach the living room. "Because you're about to become a lucky man."
"Only if you want to ruin the surprise."
"What surprise?"
I had an investment opportunity of my own.
"Walter's expensive fishing rod. Half price."
"Birdie, he'll bury you in the backyard."
I whispered so quietly Walter couldn't possibly hear me.
"I'm not actually selling it. It's a medical experiment."
I was about to cure my husband's hearing. Unfortunately, nobody had warned me about the side effects.
Only if you want to ruin the surprise.
"That sounds worse."
I lowered my voice. "Would you like to buy Walter's favorite fishing rod for a thousand dollars?"
Before Ronald could answer, our bedroom door flew open.
There stood Walter, red-faced and breathing like he'd sprinted through the Olympics.
Nobody had warned me about the side effects.
"BIRDIE! WHAT THE HELL DID YOU JUST ASK RONALD?!"
I pressed a hand to my chest. "Walter! You can hear!"
"From the living room? Through a closed door? Sweetheart, it's a miracle!"
"You're not selling my rod!"
WHAT THE HELL DID YOU JUST ASK RONALD?!
"Ronald, did you hear that? My husband's been cured!"
Ronald started laughing.
Walter pointed at my phone. "Hang up."
"Five minutes, Walter. No doctors, no expensive hearing aids."
"You're enjoying this."
Sweetheart, it's a miracle!
"More than our honeymoon."
"That's a low bar. You got food poisoning."
"And you ate my dessert."
Walter studied me for a moment. Then a sly smile crossed his face.
"Fine."
You're enjoying this.
I blinked. "Fine?"
"All right, Trouble. From now on, I'll listen to every single word you say."
"Every single one."
After fifty-eight years, I knew a husband who smiled while surrendering was planning a felony against your peace of mind.
Then a sly smile crossed his face.
He kissed my forehead and returned to his television.
Ronald whispered, "Birdie? Sleep with one eye open."
Unfortunately, he was right.
***
The following morning, Walter became the perfect husband.
It was horrifying.
Sleep with one eye open.
I entered the kitchen. He'd already made coffee.
Ah, yes. Trouble.
He'd called me that since our first date, when I talked him into sneaking into a wedding for free cake.
"Who are you?"
Walter became the perfect husband.
"Your husband."
"Where's the real Walter?"
"Watching his cholesterol."
I opened the refrigerator. "We're almost out of milk."
Walter grabbed his keys.
Who are you?
***
Twenty minutes later, he returned with two cartons.
"You said we were running out."
"One would've been enough."
"Wouldn't want my hearing to relapse."
We're almost out of milk.
He winked.
I should've recognized the warning.
Instead, I made another observation.
"These rooms could use more flowers."
"More flowers?"
Wouldn't want my hearing to relapse.
"Yes. Something cheerful."
He disappeared.
***
When he returned, he carried six flowerpots.
Then another six. Then eight more.
"Walter!"
I should've recognized the warning.
"Yes, darling?"
"Why are there twenty plants in my living room?"
"You wanted more flowers."
"You should've said bouquet."
Then another six. Then eight more.
"Why is there a cactus beside my wedding picture?"
"To represent our marriage."
"Because it's beautiful?"
"Because touching it carelessly causes pain."
He smiled sweetly.
You should've said bouquet.
But at lunchtime, I made another mistake.
"Walter, you haven't cooked dinner for me in ages."
"Actually, that would be lovely."
"Consider it done."
Touching it carelessly causes pain.
***
By six o'clock, every pot we owned was on the counter.
Walter had flour on his shirt, tomato sauce on his elbow, and something green in his hair.
"Why are you using three colanders?"
"Different stages of pasta preparation."
"You're boiling spaghetti, not performing heart surgery."
I made another mistake.
"Please don't distract the chef."
"What happened to my good frying pan?"
"Experimental garlic."
"The first batch achieved combustion."
Every pot we owned was on the counter.
I surveyed the kitchen. "Holy dentures!"
Walter lifted a wooden spoon.
The pasta was delicious.
For a moment, I remembered when Walter used to cook just to impress me. Back then, he'd even wash the dishes afterward.
The first batch achieved combustion.
Unfortunately, the kitchen resembled the aftermath of a raccoon convention.
"Walter, who's cleaning this?"
"You asked me to cook."
"You never mentioned cleaning."
The pasta was delicious.
I lowered my glasses.
"Careful, Walter. You're one complaint away from being transferred to another wife."
"I made you dinner, Birdie. Doesn't that count for something?"
"Of course it does. But look at this kitchen!"
You never mentioned cleaning.
Walter's smile faded. "There's always something I do wrong, isn't there?"
"That's not what I meant."
"Sure sounds like it," he muttered.
There it was.
My husband hadn't been cured. He'd weaponized his hearing.
Doesn't that count for something?
I could've yelled.
Instead, I smiled.
And that's when a plan began forming. I was going to put my husband in his place once and for all.
Ladies, get your notebooks ready. You might want to take notes.
He'd weaponized his hearing.
"Wonderful dinner, sweetheart."
"Tomorrow, perhaps try a recipe that doesn't require a federal cleanup crew."
***
The next afternoon, I launched my counterattack.
Walter was watching football. "Trouble, could you bring me a snack?"
I was going to put my husband in his place once and for all.
"Certainly, darling."
I returned with one grape centered on our largest dinner plate.
"You didn't specify quantity."
Walter narrowed his eyes. "Fine. Could I have a cold drink?"
I launched my counterattack.
I brought him a glass filled almost entirely with ice.
"Am I supposed to drink this or preserve a kidney?"
"You requested cold. I delivered Arctic."
He burst out laughing. "You're impossible, Birdie."
"And yet you've renewed the contract every anniversary."
You didn't specify quantity.
I considered that round a victory.
Until the following morning.
***
My glasses were missing.
So were my magazine, notebook, and favorite coffee mug.
"Walter!"
You're impossible, Birdie.
"Yes, Trouble?"
"Have you checked lost and found?"
On the counter sat a cardboard box labeled LOST AND FOUND.
Inside were all my belongings.
My glasses were missing.
"What is this?"
"Household organization."
"Why is my coffee mug here?"
"It was abandoned on the counter."
"I live here!"
Inside were all my belongings.
"Then you can claim it without identification."
"You confiscated my property!"
"Principal Birdie, please don't disrupt the classroom."
We stared at each other.
Then we both started laughing.
It was abandoned on the counter.
That annoyed me most.
He was supposed to be suffering. Instead, he was having the time of his life.
***
By the third day, I was afraid to mention toilet paper.
Something had to change. And I had a new idea.
"Walter, congratulations."
Please don't disrupt the classroom.
"For what?"
He turned off the television.
That alone was worth documenting.
"Excuse me?"
I had a new idea.
"I surrender. You've defeated me."
"Should I call the doctor?"
"Only if you want him to confirm I'm married to a suspicious old fool."
Walter studied me. "You're planning something."
"Me? Never."
That alone was worth documenting.
"Last time you said that, Ronald nearly bought my fishing rod."
"I promise not to touch your fishing equipment."
"Let's not become unreasonable."
Then I began preparing my final examination.
You're planning something.
First, I called Ronald.
"Birdie, is Walter alive?"
"For now. I need a favor."
"Does it involve fishing equipment?"
"Not this time."
I began preparing my final examination.
I asked him to print a few old photographs.
Then I opened our memory box and found a picture of Walter and me dancing.
His hair was thick, my waist was tiny, and neither had survived fifty-eight years of marriage.
I smiled and began writing my questions.
Walter appeared. "What are you doing?"
Not this time.
"Preparing for your final examination."
"After fifty-eight years? Absolutely not."
He retreated.
I smiled and began writing my questions.
***
The following evening, Ronald delivered an envelope.
Walter watched him leave. "What did he bring?"
"Against whom?"
"That depends on your answers."
"Birdie, I'd like a lawyer."
"Ronald declined representation."
Preparing for your final examination.
***
I arranged everything in the living room.
- Old photographs,
- our wedding picture,
- folded notes,
- two envelopes.
Walter entered cautiously.
Ronald delivered an envelope.
"Is this a trial?"
"What's the difference?"
"At a trial, you might get a lawyer."
He sat down. "Can I plead insanity?"
Birdie, I'd like a lawyer.
"After marrying me? Easily."
I took my seat.
"For fifty-eight years, you've heard everything about fishing, football, and pie."
"But tonight, we're testing whether you've actually listened to your wife."
Can I plead insanity?
Walter straightened. "Proceed, Principal Birdie."
I held up a photograph.
"What did I love doing when we met?"
"Correct."
We're testing whether you've actually listened to your wife.
"Especially when the band played something fast."
I smiled.
"Where was our first date?"
"The diner beside the old movie theater."
"What did I order?"
Proceed, Principal Birdie.
"Chocolate milkshake."
"You ordered strawberry. Then drank my chocolate."
He was right.
"Partial credit."
Correct.
"Naturally."
I held up another picture.
"What was I most afraid of before our wedding?"
"That my mother wouldn't like you."
"That was your fear."
He was right.
"Mine was that you'd discover I couldn't cook."
"I made excellent pasta."
"You destroyed three colanders."
He laughed.
I held up another picture.
Then his expression softened.
"You were afraid you'd have to give up teaching when we had children."
I looked at him.
I'd forgotten telling him that.
"You remember?"
You destroyed three colanders.
"Of course. On your parents' porch."
For once, I had no clever response.
"Next question, Trouble."
"What have I been wanting to do lately?"
"Go dancing again."
I'd forgotten telling him that.
"How did you know?"
"You keep looking at that photograph. And last month, you mentioned the community center's Saturday dances."
"I didn't think you heard."
"Then why didn't you say anything?"
Go dancing again.
He looked down. "I kept meaning to take you. But there was always something else."
"Football? Fishing?"
"And you thought I'd just stop asking?"
"I suppose I hoped you'd forget."
There was always something else.
"I know, Trouble. I'm sorry."
"Finally, an answer worth ten points."
Then I asked my final question.
I hoped you'd forget.
"When was our last real date? Not grocery shopping or a doctor's appointment. Just us?"
He hesitated. "Does dinner after your dental appointment count?"
"The pharmacy trip when I bought you candy?"
"No."
I asked my final question.
"Shopping for a vacuum?"
He looked down. "I don't remember."
"Neither do I."
For a moment, the room went quiet.
When was our last real date?
Walter reached across the table. "Birdie, I know I've been pretending not to hear you."
"But lately, every conversation starts with something I haven't done."
"Because there are things you haven't done."
"I know. I just got tired of feeling like a student who couldn't pass."
I don't remember.
I squeezed his hand.
"And I got tired of being the only one who remembered everything."
"I don't want to manage you, Walter."
"And I don't want to hide behind football."
Every conversation starts with something I haven't done.
"Then stop making me repeat myself."
"Stop grading me before breakfast."
"After breakfast?"
I laughed.
But I wasn't finished.
I don't want to manage you.
"There's one final assignment."
Walter groaned. "I knew there was a catch."
I handed him an envelope containing a blank card.
"Write one thing you'd like us to do together. No chores."
"Does fishing count?"
I wasn't finished.
"Unfortunately."
He wrote something. I filled out mine.
"On three."
We opened them.
There's one final assignment.
His said: TAKE BIRDIE DANCING.
Mine said: GO FISHING WITH WALTER.
He stared. "You're volunteering to go fishing?"
"Don't get emotional. I'm bringing snacks."
"After fifty-eight years, I've found someone willing to sit beside me at the lake."
He wrote something. I filled out mine.
"Don't get comfortable. I intend to catch more fish."
"You don't know how."
He grinned. "And this Saturday, I'm taking you dancing. No excuses."
"Even if there's football?"
Don't get comfortable.
"Even if there's a championship."
"You'd better mean that, Walter."
He pulled me to my feet.
We danced slowly between the coffee table and twenty flowerpots.
"Birdie?"
I'm taking you dancing. No excuses.
"Yes?"
"I know, my favorite old fool."
"Do I pass?"
I rested my head against his shoulder. "Provisionally."
Even if there's a championship.
***
The next morning, I found Walter fixing the kitchen sink.
"Without being asked? It's a miracle!"
"I deserve a diploma, Trouble."
I kissed his cheek and handed him a note: MOST IMPROVED HUSBAND.
"Any cash prize?"
My favorite old fool.
"You get to keep your fishing rod."
Later, I found him watching television.
"Walter, we're still dancing Saturday, right?"
"Sorry, Trouble. Didn't hear you."
I picked up my phone.
MOST IMPROVED HUSBAND.
"Hello, Ronald? About that fishing rod..."
Walter jumped up. "SATURDAY AT SEVEN, BIRDIE!"
- Perfect hearing.
- Five-minute treatment.
- Results guaranteed.
I'd finally learned that marriage wasn't about winning every argument, but making sure we both felt heard.