My boyfriend accused me of flirting because I laughed at his best friend's joke. Then his friend checked the time and revealed that Samuel had asked him to keep me there until midnight. I wanted to know what he'd planned, and why he was suddenly determined to leave.
"No," Samuel said. "We're leaving."
Across the dinner table, Preston lowered his wrist.
His watch had just told him it was 11:47 p.m.
"You are the one who told me to keep her here until midnight," he'd said. "Are you going to tell her why?"
"We're leaving."
Now Samuel was pushing back his chair, and I was still holding the fork I'd been about to put beside my plate.
"What happens at midnight?" I asked.
"Get your coat, Lilah."
Preston stood.
"What happens at midnight?"
"Don't do that. You asked me to have you both over. She hasn't done anything wrong."
"I wasn't talking to you."
"Samuel. What did you ask him to keep me here for?"
He pulled his jacket off the back of his chair. "Can we discuss this without an audience?"
"I wasn't talking to you."
An hour earlier, I'd been sitting sideways in that chair, comfortable enough to tuck one foot beneath me.
Preston had made pasta.
Samuel had brought the dessert I liked, a lemon tart from the bakery near his office.
He'd saved the end piece for me because it had the most crust.
Preston had made pasta.
That small kindness was still sitting on my plate.
I'd been with Samuel almost a year.
He was brilliant, awkward, and capable of spending 20 minutes explaining something before realizing that you hadn't asked how it worked.
On our first date, he'd objected to the menu's "meteorite steak."
I'd been with Samuel almost a year.
"Samuel, it's a menu."
"That doesn't excuse misinformation."
I'd laughed.
After a moment, he'd smiled, too.
Later, he'd walked me to my car and admitted he'd looked up the restaurant beforehand because he was nervous.
I'd laughed.
I liked that he told me.
I liked that he hadn't tried to turn himself into someone smoother.
When he asked to see me again, I'd said yes before he finished suggesting a day.
***
Remembering that now made it harder to pick up my purse.
I liked that he told me.
I wanted tonight to be something we could put right.
"Lilah?" Samuel held my coat out.
I took it but didn't put it on.
"We can talk privately. That doesn't mean I'm agreeing with what you said."
"Fine."
"Lilah?"
Preston moved our plates aside.
"I'm sorry," he told me. "You came here for dinner. You shouldn't have had to sit through that."
Samuel gave a short laugh. "Of course you're sorry."
"Thank you, Preston," I said.
Then I turned to Samuel.
"I'm sorry."
"He's apologized. I need an answer from you."
Samuel opened his mouth, then reached for his keys.
I said goodbye to Preston.
Outside, with Samuel several steps ahead of me, I wished I'd insisted on an answer before leaving.
Why midnight?
I said goodbye.
Samuel unlocked the car.
I got in because I wanted an explanation from my boyfriend, and for once I didn't want anyone else helping him give it.
He turned the key.
Warm air blew against my knees.
I got in.
"What did you arrange?" I asked.
"I had something planned."
"He was keeping us out of my house while someone finished getting it ready."
"Ready for what?"
"I had something planned."
"It's a surprise, Lilah."
"Then why were you angry that I was enjoying myself?"
Samuel looked over his shoulder and backed out of the parking space.
"Enjoying yourself wasn't the problem."
I waited until we reached the street. "What was?"
"It's a surprise."
"Do you really need me to explain?"
"Yes. Because you slammed your hand on a table and accused me of flirting, and I don't know what you wanted me to do differently."
He switched off the radio before it had finished connecting to his phone.
"You laughed at everything he said."
"Do you really need me to explain?"
"He was telling a story about you."
"I'm aware."
"I asked you questions. You answered them. We were all talking."
Preston had joked that the professor Samuel corrected was also grading his final.
I'd laughed, and Samuel's palm had struck the table hard enough to rattle my water glass.
"I'm aware."
At first, I'd thought he wanted us to stop telling the story.
Then he'd accused us of flirting.
Now I watched the dark storefronts pass beyond the car window.
"You could have said you didn't like the story," I told him.
"It wasn't just the story."
He'd accused us of flirting.
"Then tell me what else."
We stopped at a light.
Samuel rubbed his thumb along the steering wheel.
"You don't know what it's like sitting beside Preston. Everyone thinks he's hilarious. He can say anything, and people love him."
"Then tell me what else."
There was something in his voice I hadn't heard at the table.
For a moment, I wanted to reach across the console.
I'd seen how easily Preston could take over a conversation.
I could understand feeling crowded out. If Samuel had said that over dinner, I would have listened.
"Did you feel like we were making fun of you?"
There was something in his voice.
"Would it matter if I did?"
"Yes. That's why I'm asking."
The light changed.
"You seemed pretty happy," he said.
I pulled my hand back into my lap before he could see that I'd moved it.
"Would it matter if I did?"
***
At our first dinner, Preston had said he was impressed I'd come voluntarily.
Samuel had rolled his eyes and pulled out a chair for me.
They'd told me how Preston had rescued him from bullies during freshman year by throwing yogurt.
Samuel corrected the details; Preston insisted it had worked.
Samuel had rolled his eyes.
I'd gone home pleased that Samuel had someone who knew him that well.
Had he hated those dinners?
Had I missed something?
I turned toward him. "If you don't like how Preston talks to you, you can tell him. I'll back you up if he's being unkind. But I wasn't flirting with him."
Had I missed something?
"Would you rather have stayed there?"
The question caught me off guard.
"That's not what I said."
"You didn't seem eager to leave."
"I was asking why you'd arranged for me to stay."
"Would you rather have stayed there?"
He sighed.
"Can you let that go for five minutes?"
I looked down at my coat, folded across my knees.
I had been trying to make him stop hearing an insult in everything I said.
I'd done that before.
"Can you let that go?"
A few months earlier, a coworker named Daniel had called while Samuel and I were making dinner at my apartment.
We were preparing a presentation, and a chart in the shared file had disappeared.
I'd put Daniel on speaker while I opened my laptop.
The call lasted several minutes.
I'd done that before.
By the time I found the missing chart, Samuel had served the food.
"You could have waited until tomorrow," he'd said after I hung up.
"The presentation's at nine."
"He doesn't have anyone else he can call?"
I'd explained the project, then apologized for letting dinner get cold.
"You could have waited."
Samuel warmed our plates.
Later, he sat beside me while I practiced the presentation and pointed out a mistake I'd missed.
I'd remembered the help more clearly than the questions that came before it.
When he'd suggested adding three slides, I'd explained that I needed to keep it short. He'd started to object, then checked the timer.
I'd remembered the help.
"You're right. Show me where you want to cut."
***
The next morning, he'd texted, "You know this. Go tell them."
That was why I kept asking questions in the car.
I knew Samuel could listen when he disagreed.
I kept asking questions.
I was waiting for him to give me the same consideration he'd given a slide about quarterly expenses.
"This is like Daniel," Samuel said now.
I looked up.
"You knew how I felt after that."
"This is like Daniel."
"About interrupting dinner."
"About other men taking up our time."
"We were at your friend's house. You invited me."
He tightened his grip on the wheel.
"I shouldn't have to spell everything out."
"About interrupting dinner."
I wanted the easy evening back.
My overnight bag was in the trunk.
We'd planned to sleep late, make breakfast, and spend Saturday looking for a new couch for his living room.
He'd asked me to help choose it because I spent so much time there.
I wanted the easy evening back.
I could still make tomorrow happen.
I could say I hadn't realized how uncomfortable he'd been.
I could promise to be more careful around Preston.
But at the next dinner, what would careful look like? Smiling less?
Waiting to see whether Samuel laughed first?
"I could promise to be more careful."
"I'm sorry your feelings were hurt," I said. "But I'm not going to say I flirted with him."
Samuel didn't answer.
We drove the next block without speaking.
Then Samuel said, "Let's get inside before we finish this. The suprise I have planned will change everything."
Samuel didn't answer.
His street was just ahead.
Going to his place had been our plan all evening, but now I checked that my phone was in my pocket.
"Are you going to listen?" I asked.
He pulled into the driveway and turned off the engine.
"Are you going to listen?"
"Give me a chance to explain."
I wanted that to mean what it sounded like.
I followed him to the front door.
His sister, Nina, was standing on a kitchen chair when we walked in.
"You're early," she said, holding a loose end of ribbon. "You said midnight."
"Give me a chance to explain."
There were flowers on the coffee table.
Small lights ran along the mantel, and photographs of Samuel and me stood between them.
Two glasses waited beside a bottle in a silver bucket.
Nina climbed down.
"I still have to move the chair, and the music isn't..." She looked at my face. "What's happened?"
Nina climbed down.
Samuel shut the door.
"We had a disagreement."
"He accused me of flirting with Preston."
Nina glanced at her brother. "Do you need a minute?"
"Please," I said.
"We had a disagreement."
She took the ribbon into the kitchen.
I couldn't stop looking at the photographs.
There was one from a rainy afternoon when we'd driven to the coast and eaten sandwiches in the car.
Another showed us in my kitchen, wearing the aprons my mother had sent as a joke.
I knew what this was before Samuel opened the drawer beside the couch.
I couldn't stop looking.
"Our first date was a year ago tomorrow," he said. "I wanted to ask at midnight. Nina needed time to finish. Preston was supposed to keep us there."
He took out a small box.
For a few seconds, I could barely hold on to the argument.
I'd wondered whether he thought about marrying me.
I knew what this was.
Once, while brushing my teeth at his sink, I'd imagined my things staying there permanently.
I didn't want a different Samuel.
I wanted the man who'd sat through my presentation twice, who remembered the crust on my tart.
I'd imagined choosing that couch together, arguing over colors, then coming home to a place where neither of us had to pack a bag.
I wanted the man.
Seeing the room he'd prepared made that imagined life feel close enough to touch.
Then he stepped toward me with the box, and I remembered that he still believed I'd been flirting.
He stopped.
"Before you ask me, we need to finish talking."
He stopped.
His eyes moved toward the flowers.
"Can we have one good moment?"
"Then why are we still arguing?"
"Because you haven't taken back what you said."
"Why are we still arguing?"
Samuel set the box against his palm.
"I shouldn't have raised my voice. All right?"
Relief came so quickly that I nearly stepped closer.
Then he added, "But you have to understand how it looked."
"Do you still think I was flirting with him?"
Relief came so quickly.
He looked toward the kitchen doorway.
"Don't worry about Nina. I'm asking you."
"I think you liked the attention."
My eyes stung. I pressed my lips together until I could speak without my voice breaking.
"I liked having dinner with you and your friend. That's what I thought we were doing."
"I'm asking you."
"I spent weeks planning this."
"I can see that."
"Apparently defending Preston matters more."
"I'm not defending Preston. You keep telling me what I meant, and when I explain, you don't believe me."
"I can see that."
"If we get married, what happens the next time I laugh at someone's joke?" I asked.
"Why would you do that again when you know how I feel?"
"You know what I mean. Be more considerate."
I looked at the closed box in his hand.
"Why would you do that again?"
"So I have to watch myself around other men?"
"I'm asking you to care that it bothers me."
I waited for him to say I had misunderstood.
He only waited for me to agree.
Samuel opened the box.
I waited.
The ring was beautiful.
A small oval stone, a narrow band. I'd shown him something like it in a shop window months before, without asking for anything.
He'd remembered.
"Lilah," he said, his voice softer. "Will you marry me?"
He'd remembered.
My hand lifted before I'd decided what to say.
I could still take his hand, let him slide the ring onto my finger.
But he was still waiting for me to admit I'd encouraged Preston.
The ring hadn't changed that.
I looked at him.
I could still take his hand.
I wanted him to close the box, sit beside me, and ask what had happened to the evening.
I wanted him to be curious about my answer instead of certain he already knew it.
"I can't say yes."
His hand dropped a little.
"You were happy enough at his place."
"I can't say yes."
I slipped one arm into my coat.
"What are you doing?"
He closed the box with a sharp click. "You're throwing this away over one argument?"
"I asked whether you believed me. You answered."
"What are you doing?"
"Because I'm being honest. Would you rather I lied?"
I reached for my phone, then paused.
My bag was still in his trunk.
"I need my overnight bag."
Samuel stared at me. "So that's it?"
"Would you rather I lied?"
Nina appeared in the kitchen doorway. "Lilah, I can drive you."
I nodded before the offer could become another discussion.
Samuel moved toward me. "Do you want to be with me or not?"
I had answered that question so many times without being asked.
"I can drive you."
By clearing Fridays.
By keeping his favorite coffee at my apartment.
By believing that when something went wrong, we would eventually be able to talk about it.
Now he was asking while holding a ring and waiting for me to admit I'd hurt him.
"No," I said. "Not like this. I'm ending this, Samuel."
"Do you want to be with me or not?"
He stood still.
Behind him, one corner of a photograph had slipped off its little stand.
Nina picked up her keys.
I waited beside the door while Samuel unlocked the car with his remote, then went outside and lifted my bag from the trunk.
He stood still.
Neither of us spoke during the first few minutes of the drive.
When Nina asked which way to turn, I gave her my address.
My voice sounded ordinary, which surprised me.
I was crying by the time we reached my building.
"Thank you for bringing me," I said.
Neither of us spoke
"Of course."
Upstairs, I set my bag beside the bed.
My Saturday clothes were folded on top, with the little pouch of toiletries I'd packed that afternoon.
I hung the clothes back in my closet and put my toothbrush beside the sink.
"Of course."